MONICA YELIN: Unveiling the Harsh Truths of Immigration and Deportation as a Legal Colombian Migrant

By Monica Yelin |

Amid the ongoing discourse about immigration and deportation, widespread misconceptions persist. As a legal migrant from Colombia, I feel compelled to clarify essential points regarding this complex issue.

There exists a significant backlog for individuals already issued deportation orders. Most are not caught off guard; they have been aware of their status and have had time to prepare, especially when children are involved. This situation highlights a key challenge regarding illegal border crossings. While many come seeking asylum, simply claiming credible fear upon illegal entry does not make their actions justifiable. The reality is that a substantial number do not meet asylum qualifications, and many fail to pursue their legal hearings, which compounds the already overwhelmed system.

Critics often focus on sensational questioning rather than addressing the broader implications of immigration policies. Notably, deportation priorities typically target individuals with criminal backgrounds. It is not uncommon for undocumented individuals to be apprehended alongside these criminals, leading to their deportation as collateral damage. Accelerating the resolution of these issues requires both time and resources, underscoring the need for systemic change.

Emotions aside, it is critical to acknowledge the grim realities of human trafficking and exploitation. Many migrants fall victim to deceitful assurances of opportunity or legal status, facing life-threatening conditions during their journeys. Those who survive often arrive burdened by uncertainty and hardship.

As a legal Colombian immigrant, I feel justified in voicing my concern. The previous administration’s approach appears to have neglected the rule of law, placing both legal immigrants and citizens at a disadvantage. The treatment of migrants under these policies has raised alarm, further exacerbated by foreign leaders like Colombian President Gustavo Petro, who appear to be manipulating the crisis for political gain.

Critically, one must consider the allocation of resources. Why are we prioritizing undocumented migrants when numerous veterans, individuals battling addiction, and homeless citizens remain without adequate support? Many legal residents and natural-born Americans feel overlooked as billions are directed overseas. Moreover, DACA recipients and others waiting for resolution have been left in limbo.

The agony experienced by Angel Parents—those mourning children lost to crimes committed by undocumented migrants—serves as a chilling reminder of the immigration crisis’s human toll.

While it is imperative to have compassion for all individuals, including undocumented migrants, the previous administration’s oversight of the needs of legal immigrants and citizens is undeniable. Many rightful applicants await family reunification, enduring a seemingly endless wait, while refugees in camps overseas lose hope for a better future.

Furthermore, it is essential to consider undocumented individuals who have resided here for decades, who contribute positively to society through work and taxation, raising U.S. citizen children. Their frustration over neglect in policy discussions cannot be dismissed.

While I firmly oppose illegal immigration, we must confront the reality that many are already here. Implementing a structured path to residency, with stringent criteria for long-term residents who have maintained good conduct, could serve as a viable solution—one that does not condone illegal entry but recognizes current realities.

Ultimately, a fair and logical immigration system must balance compassion with the law. This involves addressing those who threaten public safety while simultaneously creating pathways for those eager to contribute positively to society. Striving for a balance that ensures dignity for all within the framework of the law is essential for a just immigration policy.

Monica Yelin is the Executive Director of the Hispanic Liberty Alliance.