Tax on Mexican Tomatoes Casts Shadow Over Cinco de Mayo Festivities

In a shift affecting the agricultural landscape, the U.S. government plans to impose a nearly 21% duty on fresh Mexican tomatoes starting July 14, while previously threatened tariffs on avocados remain on hold. This tax, targeting 4 billion pounds of tomatoes imported annually from Mexico, raises significant concerns among various stakeholders.

Proponents argue that the duty aims to rejuvenate the dwindling U.S. tomato industry and promote domestic production. Currently, around 70% of U.S. tomatoes are sourced from Mexico, a dramatic rise from just 30% two decades ago, according to the Florida Tomato Exchange.

Key figures, like Robert Guenther of the Florida Tomato Exchange, emphasize the need for fair pricing to sustain a viable domestic industry. Florida and California lead the U.S. in tomato production, yet much of California’s harvest is processed into other products.

However, critics suggest the duty will inflate prices for U.S. consumers. NatureSweet, which cultivates tomatoes in both Mexico and the U.S., fears that millions in duties will soon burden its operations. Skip Hulett, the company’s chief legal officer, stated, “We’re always adapting, but these added costs will inevitably be passed on to the consumer.” Tim Richards, a professor at Arizona State University, estimates that retail prices could rise by about 10.5% with the new tariffs.

The Mexican government is keen to negotiate the situation, yet the potential for retaliatory measures looms large. President Claudia Sheinbaum hinted that Mexico might respond with its own tariffs on U.S. chicken and pork imports.

The history of tomato trade regulations is intricate. Following the North American Free Trade Agreement’s implementation in 1996, a U.S. investigation into alleged dumping led to a minimum pricing agreement between the two countries. However, the recent withdrawal from this agreement has reignited tensions.

Guenther argues that despite minimum price requirements, Mexican exporters often evade checks, thus impacting U.S. growers adversely. He suggests that factors such as lower land and labor costs in Mexico create an unlevel playing field. In comparison, U.S. farmers rely on the H-2A program, which mandates higher wages, exacerbating their operational costs.

NatureSweet recognizes the advantages of Mexican agriculture, primarily due to favorable climate conditions that reduce the need for heating, cooling, and lighting in greenhouses.

Trade representatives like Lance Jungmeyer point out that Florida does not produce the specialty tomatoes increasingly favored by consumers. This gap has allowed Mexican imports to flourish, further complicating the local industry’s position.

Adrian Burciaga, co-owner of Don Artemio in Fort Worth, Texas, shared concerns about flavor and quality. With 300 to 400 pounds of Mexican Roma tomatoes required weekly for his restaurant, he faces pressure from rising operational costs. “The uncertainty makes it hard for budget planning. We can’t anticipate these shifts,” he remarked.

As the deadline approaches for the new duties, the agricultural sector braces for changes that may ripple through consumer prices and supply chains.

Copyright 2025 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.