Supervisor Candidates Divided Over Support for Pima County’s PEEPS Preschool Initiative

Pima County’s initiative to support parents with early childhood education costs has generated mixed responses among candidates for the Pima County Board of Supervisors in the upcoming Nov. 5 election. Established in 2021, the Pima Early Education Program Scholarships assist children aged 3 to 5 in attending local early education programs. Funding comes from the county’s allocation of the federal American Rescue Plan Act, supplemented by contributions from the city of Tucson, the towns of Marana and Oro Valley, and the United Way of Tucson & Southern Arizona, which also receives private donations.

The program saw expenditures of approximately $10 million in fiscal year 2024. When federal funds expire, the county plans to draw from special property taxes earmarked for library support to continue funding. Eligible families can receive assistance if they earn up to 300% of the federal poverty level, equating to $93,600 for a family of four. In its third year, the program benefited over 1,900 children, as noted in the 2024 annual report.

The candidates’ positions are varied regarding the program’s future. In District 1, incumbent Pima County Supervisor Rex Scott expressed support for the initiative, highlighting its significance for educational preparedness. Scott emphasized that without assistance, struggling families face disadvantages in affording preschool, with average monthly costs around $800 per child. He framed the issue as both an educational and economic development concern, noting broad support from local chambers and businesses that value stable childcare options for their employees. His opponent, Republican Steve Spain, has not articulated his stance on PEEPS but has criticized county spending.

In District 2, Supervisor Matt Heinz also voiced his pride in the program and emphasized its importance in providing early educational support to families. His challenger, Republican John Backer, acknowledges the program’s role in supplementing state aid but suggests possible reforms to make it more needs-based and efficient.

District 3 candidates express differing views on PEEPS. Democrat Jen Allen identifies the program as essential to Pima County’s Prosperity Initiative, whereas Republican Janet “JL” Wittenbraker argues it represents government overreach, suggesting existing state and charitable programs suffice.

Supervisor Steve Christy from District 4 opposes the program, questioning the claimed benefits of early childhood education and advocating for a focus on state-level solutions instead. His opponent, Vanessa Bechtol, counters that the program not only fosters educational success but supports working families needing secure childcare.

In District 5, Supervisor Adelita Grijalva champions the initiative for its dual role in assisting families and ensuring children start school with a solid foundation. Independent candidate Val Romero also supports the program, emphasizing its positive impact on early education in the community.