Ranger Barn Preserves Its Historical Charm for the Time Being

In a recent Sedona City Council meeting, it was decided that the historic Ranger Station barn will maintain its character during renovations. The council voted against insulating and sheetrocking the barn or installing central heating and cooling systems, allowing it to serve as an open-air event venue for the time being.

Parks and Recreation Manager Josh Frewin presented two redevelopment options to the council. The first proposal aimed to preserve the barn’s signature open-air design, aligning with the Historic Preservation Commission’s preference. “It keeps that barn feel that people are renting it for,” Frewin noted. However, he acknowledged that while this option might limit summer and winter rentals, it would reduce public spending and potentially increase usage of the nearby air-conditioned rangers’ house.

The second option involved modernizing the barn with insulation and central climate control systems at an estimated cost of roughly $119,000. Frewin argued this would allow for year-round rentals suitable for displaying art but would compromise the barn’s rustic character and limit events that benefit from its open-door setup.

Frewin cited financial data showing revenue generation from similar venues, noting the Sedona Posse Grounds Hub earned $18,412 in fiscal year 2024, while the Barbara Antonsen Memorial Park generated $8,037. He mentioned the city currently shuts off water to the pavilion between October and March, rendering it unavailable for events.

Councilwoman Kathy Kinsella inquired about revisiting climate control options in the future. Facilities Maintenance Manager Larry Farhat assured the council that the project could move forward with the installation of ventilation fans at no additional cost besides potential inflation changes. He also mentioned existing portable evaporative coolers could help manage summer heat.

Public Works Director Kurt Harris endorsed the swamp coolers as an effective solution, while Vice Mayor Holli Ploog introduced the idea of a cheaper “mini-split” system for future consideration. However, Councilman Brian Fultz expressed concern about the aesthetic implications of adding such systems. Any modifications would also require evaluation from both the Historic Preservation Commission and the State Historic Preservation Office to ensure historical integrity is not compromised.

The council discussed refinishing the barn’s concrete floor, with costs ranging from $15,000 to $18,000. Fultz suggested skipping this optional aesthetic improvement, stressing the importance of preserving the barn’s historic character. Other council members echoed the sentiment that any changes should be carefully considered, with some advocating for a wait-and-see approach regarding future usage.

Kinsella humorously suggested introducing chickens and goats to enhance the barn’s authentic atmosphere, while Mayor Scott Jablow recommended revisiting the heating and cooling options next year after gathering feedback from users. The council ultimately agreed to proceed with floor polishing, while keeping the door open for more significant climate control discussions in the future.