Pope Francis and JD Vance: Unpacking Their Controversial Easter Meeting Before the Pope’s Passing

In a poignant turn of events, Pope Francis passed away at the age of 88 on Monday, a day after his final public appearance during Easter celebrations. His death marks the end of a significant era for the Catholic Church.

Vice President JD Vance had a fleeting yet notable meeting with the pope over the weekend, highlighting both personal and political dimensions. This encounter occurred against a backdrop of previously strained dialogues regarding immigration policies during the Trump administration.

Following the announcement of the pope’s passing, Vance took to social media to express his condolences. “I just learned of the passing of Pope Francis. My heart goes out to the millions of Christians all over the world who loved him,” he wrote, noting the pope’s frail condition during their meeting. Vance recalled the significance of Francis’ homily during the early pandemic days, describing it as profoundly moving.

During their meeting, captured on video by the Vatican, Vance greeted the pope, who was seated in a wheelchair, and a priest served as an interpreter. Vance’s warmth was evident when he stated, “So good to see you. I know you’ve not been feeling great, but it’s good to see you in better health.” While the pope’s responses were inaudible, he graciously presented gifts, including chocolate eggs for Vance’s children, symbolizing the personal connection they shared.

The meeting had a political undertone, as Vance also engaged in discussions with Cardinal Pietro Parolin and Archbishop Paul Gallagher about their mutual faith, the state of Catholicism in the U.S., and the global challenges faced by Christian communities. The Vatican described these discussions as an “exchange of opinions” on pressing issues, including immigration.

Pope Francis was a vocal advocate for migrants and refugees throughout his papacy, often opposing stringent U.S. immigration policies. Just days before his hospitalization, he criticized the deportation strategies proposed by the Trump administration, emphasizing the dignity of migrants. In response, Vance defended the administration’s approach through a theological framework, asserting a hierarchy of care that prioritizes family and community.

In a letter addressing U.S. bishops, the pope offered a counter-narrative, urging a more inclusive interpretation of Christian love, referencing the parable of the “Good Samaritan.” Vance acknowledged the pope’s critiques but maintained his stance on immigration policy, admitting his own learning journey within the Church following his conversion in 2019.