Mayor-Elect of Surprise Exposes Outgoing Mayor Amid Controversial Arrest at City Council Meeting

By Matthew Holloway |

Rebekah Massie, a mother from Surprise, Arizona, ignited fierce debate during a city council meeting last week. She criticized the council’s decision to grant a salary increase to City Attorney Robert Wingo, citing multiple alleged violations related to Arizona’s legal standards and ethical conduct. Massie emphasized Wingo’s role in handling contentious allegations regarding the city clerk’s management of elections.

The situation escalated when outgoing Mayor Skip Hall ordered her removal from the meeting. This directive culminated in Massie’s arrest and citation, raising eyebrows about free speech rights in public forums.

Mayor-Elect Kevin Sartor responded swiftly, condemning Hall’s actions. “As Americans, our right to free speech is fundamental,” Sartor stated, adding that no citizen should face arrest for expressing concerns. He reiterated his commitment to transparency and the protection of First Amendment rights within his administration.

Massie, affiliated with The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), voiced her concerns regarding Wingo’s pay hike, especially given his role in the city’s election oversight. She highlighted that Wingo’s salary of $266,000 is already one of the highest in the city.

During her address, Massie called attention to perceived violations under state statutes and ethical guidelines, indicating that the city had failed to address significant issues in election management. “Nothing was done with those violations,” she remarked, underscoring a lack of accountability.

As she continued her remarks, Hall intervened, citing protocols that stifle personal allegations against city employees. An argument ensued, with Massie asserting her First Amendment rights. “This is factual information,” she contended, only to be dismissed by Hall, who insisted on the formality of the meeting procedures.

As tensions rose, Hall requested police intervention to escort Massie out. Despite her protests, a Surprise police officer appeared to remove her from the proceedings. Massie refused to leave quietly, questioning the legality of her detainment in front of her young daughter. She was ultimately charged with third-degree trespassing.

Following the incident, FIRE announced its intent to file a lawsuit on behalf of Massie, asserting that her right to criticize public officials without fear of arrest is protected by the First Amendment. Massie affirmed her commitment to stand up for free speech rights, citing her responsibilities as a citizen and a mother.

This incident not only highlights concerns over free speech in municipal proceedings but also raises questions about the accountability and ethical standards expected from public officials. As the city grapples with the fallout, the commitment to open dialogue will be put to the test.

Matthew Holloway is a reporter for AZ Free News. Follow him on X for the latest updates.