Crumbl’s Bold New Flavors Spark Cookie Lovers’ Curiosity for Pies

If you’ve visited the Crumbl Cookies on John Wayne Parkway lately, you may have noticed an exciting shift in their offerings.

The beloved cookie chain has expanded its menu, now including two new cookie varieties each week alongside an array of desserts like cakes, pies, and puddings. This shift marks a pivotal moment leading up to the holidays, as they unveil a dedicated pie menu in time for Thanksgiving.

Local fans can now pre-order from Crumbl’s new selection of mini desserts in preparation for Turkey Day. The menu features six pie options alongside a single cookie to tantalize taste buds: French silk pie, apple pie, cookies and cream pie, key lime pie, pumpkin pie, and pecan pie, paired with a classic double chocolate chip cookie.

Each pie will be priced at an additional $0.99, and customers can choose between “large” 5-inch and mini 3-inch sizes. To accommodate larger gatherings, Crumbl also offers multi-packs of four to 12 pies, packaged in their signature pink boxes.

The news of a pie introduction, however, has generated mixed feelings. A preview of the Thanksgiving week menu surfaced on Reddit last month, sparking discussions among users. While some expressed enthusiasm for the new options, the response was not universally positive.

One user shared their excitement, noting the return of the cherry cheesecake, while others voiced skepticism. Negative feedback included remarks such as, “Ew wtf are those pies,” reflecting a divide in public opinion.

With these new dessert offerings, Crumbl aims to expand its appeal beyond cookies during the holiday season, prompting fans and critics alike to weigh in on the changes.