Coverage of Extremism and Abortion Catapults the Mirror to AZ Media Association’s Pinnacle of Honor

The Arizona Mirror secured eight prestigious awards in the inaugural Arizona Media Association Better Newspapers Contest, leading its division in 2024.

Since its establishment in 2018, the Mirror has been a significant voice in Arizona politics and government reporting. Its accolades include recognition for coverage on critical issues such as abortion rights, Kari Lake’s election challenge, homelessness, and the plight of Indigenous victims of Medicaid fraud.

Chris Fitzsimon, publisher of States Newsroom, praised the Mirror’s achievements, noting the dedication of its reporters and editors. “It’s an honor to see the Arizona Mirror’s great work recognized, but it’s no surprise,” he remarked.

Among the standout honorees was Jerod MacDonald-Evoy, who won the award for best news story for his investigative reporting on Arizona State University’s substantial spending on security for a controversial speaker. He revealed that ASU spent over $11,000 to ensure the safety of white nationalist Jared Taylor during a 2022 event.

Mirror Editor in Chief Jim Small also received recognition, earning first place for his compelling column series addressing the GOP’s reaction to the reinstatement of an 1864 near-total abortion ban. His insights highlighted potential health risks associated with the law and its implications during an election year.

Caitlin Sievers, the Mirror’s deputy editor, earned a second place award for her sustained coverage of Kari Lake’s trial aimed at overturning her 2022 election defeat. Her comprehensive reporting not only followed the trial’s developments but also demystified complex legal issues for readers.

Shondiin Silversmith, recognized for her coverage of Indigenous affairs, received a second place award for her narrative on Operation Rainbow Bridge. This initiative focused on aiding tribal members affected by fraudulent sober living homes, showcasing her commitment to impactful journalism.

Gloria Rebecca Gomez also earned a third place award for her detailed reporting on the 1864 abortion ban, emphasizing the political fallout and healthcare access issues resulting from the law’s reinstatement.

MacDonald-Evoy’s dive into the homelessness crisis in the Valley also garnered him a third place award in enterprise reporting, showcasing the human side of this pressing issue.

Small’s investigative analysis on legislative pay disparities earned a third place in its category, reflecting an ongoing issue within the state’s political structure. The Mirror’s eight awards tied it with the Casa Grande Dispatch for the most honors in its division at the contest.