Arizona Pastor Murder: Suspect’s Shocking Confession Revealed in Jailhouse Interview

COCONINO COUNTY, Ariz. — Adam Sheafe, the man accused of murdering Pastor Bill Schonemann, has confessed to the crime in a jailhouse interview with 12News. Speaking from his cell, Sheafe not only admitted to the killing but also revealed he had intentions to target more religious leaders across the nation.

Sheafe claimed his motives stem from a twisted interpretation of religious doctrine. He referred to his violent plans as “Operation First Commandment,” expressing a belief that Jesus Christ contradicts fundamental biblical commandments. “His commandments have been annulled by this character called Jesus, a human being who I believe is the son of Satan,” Sheafe stated.

The suspect’s journey led him from California to Arizona, where he meticulously planned the murder of Schonemann, who had served as pastor in New River for over three decades. Sheafe relayed how he stalked the pastor during a Wednesday evening Bible study before returning to execute his plan on a Sunday. He described his actions in chilling detail, though specific mentions of the crime were omitted for respect toward Schonemann’s family.

Following the murder on April 28, Sheafe attempted to flee to Sedona, aiming to kill two more priests at the Chapel of the Holy Cross. His pursuit ended with a high-speed police chase. “Had I been better prepared… I don’t think there would have been any way to stop me,” Sheafe remarked, acknowledging the officers who intervened and potentially saved lives.

Currently in custody, Sheafe is awaiting extradition back to Maricopa County. He expressed no desire for a trial, instead demanding to be sent to death row. “Put me on death row, set the execution date for right now,” he stated, suggesting that both he and the victims’ families seek closure.

Sheafe controversially claimed that execution would not end his existence, describing it merely as separating the spirit from the flesh. As the situation develops, concerns remain over the psychological state and motivations of individuals like Sheafe, raising questions about broader societal issues related to religious extremism.