Arizona Judge Nixes Controversial $15 Million Prescott Rodeo Project

Two Arizona citizens have successfully sued the state over a controversial allocation of $15 million for the renovation of a rodeo facility.

PRESCOTT, Arizona — A Maricopa County judge, Scott Blaney, has ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, stating that the taxpayer-funded rodeo project violates the Arizona Constitution’s Gift Clause. This clause prevents the state from donating public funds without proving a legitimate public purpose.

The legislative appropriations in question were approved in 2023, directing $15.3 million to enhance the grounds of “The World’s Oldest Rodeo.” Judge Blaney highlighted that the lack of a clear public benefit undermines the justification for such funding.

“With no stated purpose or limitations on the use of the public’s money, the Court cannot find that the Appropriation would serve a public purpose,” Blaney stated in his decision.

The judge also noted that the financial commitment far exceeds any benefits the public might receive in return. Consequently, the ruling effectively halts the renovation plans and allows the plaintiffs to seek attorney’s fees.

This funding originated from an agreement between Governor Katie Hobbs and state legislators, allowing them to earmark a portion of surplus revenue. Lawmakers directed funds to the nonprofit managing the Prescott rodeo.

Concerns regarding the appropriation have intensified, particularly in light of increasing wildfire risks in the area. Critics are urging state leaders to repurpose the allocated funds towards public safety and wildfire prevention initiatives.

Despite these objections, State Senator Mark Finchem remains a vocal supporter of the rodeo project. He recently introduced a bill aimed at rerouting the funds through the City of Prescott, attempting to address concerns related to the Gift Clause.

Judge Blaney’s decision reinforces the complexities surrounding public funding and private projects, raising questions about fiscal responsibility in state allocations.

RELATED: Prescott residents suing Arizona for giving $15M to rodeo organizers