Advocates Push for Permanent Legal Support for Phoenix Renters Facing Eviction

PHOENIX — The City of Phoenix is facing growing pressure to make its temporary right to counsel program for tenants a permanent fixture amid a surge in eviction cases. Since July 2020, the city has allocated millions in federal funding to support the Tenants Eviction Assistance Project, yet advocates argue that more robust, city-funded support is necessary.

Recent data reveals that 7,957 eviction cases were filed in Maricopa County in August. This figure represents the second-highest monthly total recorded, just shy of the over 8,000 cases filed in January 2024.

Councilwoman Kesha Hodge Washington, representing District 8, voiced her concerns during a press conference held outside Phoenix City Hall. “Some may ask, ‘Why should the government pay for tenants’ lawyers?’ The answer is simple: we already bear the cost of evictions, and those costs are considerably higher,” she explained.

The councilwoman referenced Philadelphia’s $3.5 million investment in right to counsel since February 2022, which led to an estimated $45.2 million in cost savings. “I think that’s a worthwhile investment,” Hodge Washington said.

Despite the clear imbalance—with nearly all landlords securing legal representation while less than 1% of tenants have counsel according to the William E. Morris Institute for Justice—the right to counsel remains temporary in Phoenix. Pamela Bridge, director of advocacy and litigation at Community Legal Services, highlighted the stakes. “It’s an uneven balance of power,” she said, emphasizing the vulnerable position tenants face during eviction hearings.

Bridge noted that legal representation allows for a deeper examination of eviction claims, including their validity and adherence to complicated federal regulations. “We can negotiate with the landlord to try to reach a settlement, even if there’s no legal basis for the eviction,” she added.

In response to the urgent need for more comprehensive support, the Phoenix Industrial Development Authority is conducting a cost-benefit analysis. Advocates from the Take Back Our Homes campaign believe the findings will demonstrate the economic advantages of permanent funding for legal counsel.

“We need decisive action to pass legislation that helps people stay in their homes,” urged Catherine Wilkins from the campaign, emphasizing the looming homelessness crisis.

Personal testimonies serve as stark reminders of the consequences of inadequate legal support. Meisha Fish recounted her abrupt eviction six years ago, highlighting her vulnerability. “I was unprepared. He knocked at the door… I had no recourse,” she recounted, her situation underscoring the critical need for tenant representation.

For those facing eviction, Bridge stresses the importance of seeking help immediately. “Don’t assume things will improve next week. Communicate with your landlord and seek legal counsel as soon as possible,” she advised, stating that prompt action allows for better negotiation opportunities.

Community Legal Services offers assistance both online and in person at designated locations during the week, aiming to extend vital support to those in need.