WATCH: MPD Unveils 40 Cold Cases to State Amidst Internal Investigation Revelations

The Maricopa Police Department is facing scrutiny after a review revealed potential investigative failures in over 40 criminal cases spanning more than a decade. Chief of Police Mark Goodman announced this development today.

The issues surfaced during a comprehensive audit of “legacy” cases, which include both property theft and serious offenses like sexual assault. Goodman described the findings as having “troubling deficiencies,” pointing out that many cases were closed with no evident investigation.

“This is unacceptable and does not reflect the high-quality police department that serves our community,” Goodman stated, emphasizing a commitment to rectify the situation.

In response, at least 40 cases have been referred to the Arizona Department of Public Safety for an independent investigation. DPS has accepted this referral and is actively examining the circumstances.

The exact scope of the uncovered issues remains unclear. Goodman highlighted that some cases involve serious allegations that lacked appropriate follow-up, including concerns about untested rape kits, which can lead to significant backlogs.

“Every case — and every person behind that case — deserves a thorough and fair investigation,” he asserted. “We are committed to doing right by the victims.”

This internal review is part of Goodman’s broader initiative to enhance transparency and accountability within the department. Alongside the DPS investigation, MPD has reopened several affected cases and is implementing new oversight measures.

Steps being taken include improving the investigative review process, fostering collaboration among leadership, and requiring additional supervisory approvals before closing any case. Further internal reforms will depend on the DPS investigation’s outcomes.

The department is urging residents with concerns about older cases to reach out to Lt. Kathleen Elliott for assistance.

Goodman reiterated the department’s dedication to upholding professional standards and maintaining community trust.

“We thank the Maricopa community for its continued support as we work to uphold the standards of professionalism and integrity that you expect from us,” he said.

The DPS investigation is ongoing, with no timeline provided for when the findings will be disclosed.

Although the full extent of the deficiencies has yet to be established, Goodman pledged to make the DPS investigation’s findings public once completed.

“We believe transparency is essential to earning and maintaining your trust,” he added.

InMaricopa has reached out to AZDPS for further details on the cases involved in the investigation, but state police declined to comment.

“Per policy, we never comment on ongoing investigations,” stated spokesman Bart Graves.