Arizona Revives Death Penalty: Executions Set to Resume After 2-Year Hiatus Following Gov. Hobbs’ Controversial Firing

PHOENIX — Arizona is set to resume executions in 2025, following Democratic Governor Katie Hobbs’ decision to dismiss retired Judge David Duncan from overseeing the state’s execution protocols. This move comes shortly after Hobbs, who assumed office in January 2023, initiated an independent review of the state’s execution practices.

Initially, Hobbs expressed confidence in Duncan’s abilities, emphasizing the need for a transparent and effective review process due to Arizona’s troubled history with executions. In a letter to Duncan, however, she voiced a loss of confidence in his ability to deliver the necessary report, citing concerns over his understanding of the review’s scope and his controversial recommendation of firing squads as a method of execution, which is not sanctioned by current state law.

Duncan, who previously served as a federal magistrate judge, expressed disappointment at his termination. He argued that his work aligned with the executive order’s goals and highlighted his commitment to uncovering the truth in the review process.

Despite this setback, Hobbs’ office conveyed assurance that the Arizona Department of Corrections has prepared for future executions, which will be the first since the governor took office. Corrections Director Ryan Thornell communicated to Hobbs that his department is operationally ready to carry out executions, solidifying the state’s commitment to adhering to constitutional standards in the process.

In a related development, Arizona’s Attorney General Kris Mayes announced plans to seek an execution warrant for Aaron Brian Gunches, sentenced to death in 2008 for the murder and kidnapping of Ted Price. Mayes reaffirmed her commitment to seeking justice for victims and their families, signaling a renewed push for executions as the state prepares for the legal proceedings ahead.