Arizona Supreme Court
Hobbs Taps Appellate Judge Maria Elena Cruz for Supreme Court Role

By Matthew Holloway |
On January 29, Governor Katie Hobbs appointed Appellate Court Judge Maria Elena Cruz to succeed Supreme Court Justice Robert Brutinel, who announced his retirement scheduled for 2024. Cruz, during her remarks, underscored her commitment to issues affecting marginalized communities.
In a news conference, Hobbs stated, “I prioritized an appointee who is not only eminently qualified, but also someone who reflects our state and is committed to making our legal system work for everyday people,” as reported by AZCentral. She emphasized the importance of credentials while also seeking a justice who would advocate for those in need.
Cruz’s legal career spans extensive experience, having practiced in various jurisdictions and roles, including both defense and prosecution. She expressed pride in her heritage alongside family during the announcement, remarking, “For many, this day is long overdue. And so today, we celebrate.”
She articulated her respect for the rule of law, shaped by her experiences living and working in rural Arizona. Cruz highlighted her personal insight into the challenges faced by marginalized individuals, indicating a holistic approach to her judicial responsibilities.
Hobbs characterized Cruz as “a Justice who gives a voice to working-class people in every corner of our state,” showcasing the broader implications of this appointment beyond just diversity.
Cruz has served on the Arizona Court of Appeals since 2017, having been appointed by former Governor Doug Ducey. Notably, she ruled against the Arizona Senate on issues related to the controversial 2020 election audit. Her judgment mandated that Cyber Ninjas, the third-party firm involved in the recount, release critical documentation, reinforcing the importance of transparency in the legislative process.
She wrote for a three-judge panel that “allowing the legislature to disregard the clear mandate of the public records law would undermine the integrity of the legislative process,” as reported by NBC News. Cruz argued that public records should remain accessible regardless of their custodian.
Further, Cruz’s application highlighted her commitment to equality, referencing her role in officiating same-sex marriages in Yuma County after the change in law. She explained, “I had to stand up … for the law,” despite potential backlash, reiterating the ideals of judicial integrity and fairness.
Matthew Holloway is a senior reporter for AZ Free News. Follow him on X for his latest stories, or email tips to Matthew@azfreenews.com.