City Council Axes Controversial ‘Criticism Policy’ Amid Outcry

By Matthew Holloway |

The Surprise City Council has unanimously voted to repeal an ordinance that barred residents from criticizing city officials during public meetings. This decision follows the arrest of local activist Rebekah Massie, who was detained while expressing her opinions in August. In the aftermath, Massie, alongside the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), has initiated a lawsuit against the city, which is currently in progress.

In a statement received by AZ Free News, FIRE’s attorney Conor Fitzpatrick expressed gratitude for the council’s decision but acknowledged the harm already inflicted. “The city council’s decision to scrap its unconstitutional rule banning criticism of public officials is the right move — but the damage has already been done,” Fitzpatrick stated. He referenced Massie’s arrest, which occurred precisely 28 days prior, accusing Mayor Skip Hall of misusing his authority to silence dissent at the meeting.

Councilman Jack Hastings spearheaded the initiative to abolish the controversial policy. Earlier this week, he announced on X, “I will make a motion to remove the rule that prohibits complaints against elected officials during the public comment portion of our meetings. I support the freedom of speech, and people should be able to voice their concerns.” Hastings further conveyed his hope that the motion would pass unanimously, emphasizing the necessity for elected officials to withstand criticism.

The legal action against the city, filed on September 3, targets outgoing Mayor Hall and Surprise police officer Steven Shernicoff individually. The lawsuit seeks both a temporary and permanent injunction against the enforcement of the Council Criticism Policy and claims that the policy infringed upon Massie’s First Amendment rights. Additionally, the case requests compensatory, nominal, and punitive damages for the wrongful arrest, along with legal fees.

In response to the incident, Mayor-Elect Kevin Sartor condemned the previous administration’s actions. “What happened to Rebekah Massie is unacceptable. No citizen should ever be arrested for voicing their concerns, especially in a forum designed for public input,” Sartor stated. He emphasized the significance of free speech in promoting governmental accountability and assured that he would foster an environment where every citizen’s voice is both heard and respected. “We are stronger when every voice is heard,” he concluded.

Matthew Holloway is a reporter for AZ Free News. Follow him on X for the latest updates, or email tips to Matthew@azfreenews.com.