America’s Hometown Heroes Rally for Local Control in Phoenix

By Paul Parisi |

On August 26, 2024, a significant gathering took place at the Phoenix City Council meeting as members of Our America Hometown Heroes advocated for local control of the Phoenix Police Department (PPD). Donning their distinctive yellow T-shirts, these participants voiced their support during the public comment session, emphasizing the necessity for Phoenix to manage its own police force free from federal oversight.

Conversely, a smaller contingent of Black Lives Matter (BLM) activists also attended, demanding a DOJ Consent Decree to impose court oversight on the PPD. Their call for action was fueled by a controversial June report from the U.S. Department of Justice, which criticized the PPD and prompted federal intervention despite the department’s ongoing reform efforts.

The presence of Our America was strengthened by leaders from minority organizations, including BLEXIT Arizona, the Hispanic Liberty Alliance, and the Independent Women’s Network. This coalition represents a unified voice advocating for maintaining local governance.

During the meeting, four representatives from Our America articulated their positions, imploring the Phoenix mayor and council to sustain reforms that have already led to a notable decrease in crime while also protecting citizens’ civil rights.

Bella Ceballos-Viner, reflecting on her extensive positive experiences with law enforcement over the past quarter-century, emphasized that her sentiments echoed those of many within the Hispanic and African-American communities who support the police. “For over 25 years, I have had nothing but great experiences,” she affirmed, highlighting the essential role of community trust in law enforcement.

Another advocate, Christy Narsi from the Independent Women’s Network, passionately warned against the pitfalls of DOJ Consent Decrees in other cities, urging the council to maintain local control. “I urge you not to surrender local autonomy by allowing federal overreach to steal control of our local law enforcement and the city they serve,” she stated, arguing that local policing decisions should remain in the hands of those who understand the community best.

The ongoing discourse surrounding the PPD epitomizes a broader national debate over the balance between federal intervention and local authority in policing. Our America asserts that safer communities are best achieved through policing and criminal justice reforms tailored specifically to local needs. The existing reforms instituted by the PPD illustrate the efficacy of community-led initiatives.

As City of Phoenix officials confront pressure from the DOJ regarding a potential Consent Decree, the local advocates will significantly influence the city’s future direction. By championing local control, Our America Hometown Heroes stand firm not only for the Phoenix Police Department’s autonomy but also for the belief that communities thrive when they actively participate in their governance.

Paul Parisi is the Arizona Grassroots Director for Our America.